Lure Fish Bar

142 Mercer Street
New York, NY

Ranking: 15


Though often compared to the In and Out burger, this is far from a fast food restaurant. Lure Fish Bar provides an experience that was quite surprising - perhaps the biggest surprise of any burger we have sampled yet. A full on seafood restaurant, the burger is not to be missed. The menu offers two options - the "Cheeseburger" or the "Lure Burger". Splurge for the little extra money and order the Lure. Served with pickles, tomato, cheese, lettuce, ketchup, and mustard, the burger is topped with two nice sized onion rings on top of the bun. The burger, comprised on fresh ground chuck, is cut in half before it is served. The burger is served up on a brioche roll that is both sturdy enough to support the burger, sweet enough to add some flavor, and light enough not to interfere. The burger comes with a side of shoestring type fries compete with three dipping sauces. A very satisfying and fulfilling meal. Great service and friendly staff round off this great experience.


Pleasantly Surprised

I have been to Lure a number of times but never had the burger.  After seeing Lure listed on this site I tried it and was pleasantly surprised.  Next time I am there I will have to decide: Fish or Burger??

­©2009 Burger Rankings, LLC. All Rights Reserved
Terms of Service / Privacy Policy